SUNBURY - A former Major League Baseball pitcher's conduct toward his ex-fiancee did not place her in fear of bodily injury, a Northumberland County hearing officer ruled Friday, denying her request for a permanent protection from abuse order.
Marsha Skoff's determination was made a day after a four-hour hearing Thursday during which Steve Kline, 42, of Winfield, and Heather L. Sawyer, 36, of Sunbury, testified on each other's conduct over the past several months. A temporary PFA had been granted by the court Sept. 12.
Judge Anthony Rosini, who granted the original PFA, signed the order approving Skoff's recommendation Thursday.
Kline "never physically harmed (Sawyer) at any time during their relationship and she did not testify to threats to harm her," Skoff wrote. "As such, the plaintiff's request for a final protection order is denied.
Kline is currently on paid leave from his primary employer, the San Francisco Giants, where he coaches in the minor league system, to straighten out the issue,
Sawyer claimed in filing for the PFA that Kline was harassing and stalking her, leaving notes on the door of her mother's residence, visiting family members and following them.
Kline said he was merely looking for Sawyer because he alleges she stole from him and, in one case, to deliver a bill for which he said she was responsible.
"(Kline) did not threaten bodily harm to (Sawyer) in any of letters or verbally at any time, but did threaten legal action and criminal charges against (Sawyer) for theft if she did not repay him for the items she took," Skoff wrote.
Sawyer testified that Kline gave her permission to take whatever she needed to "move on and start a new life."
Skoff noted in her report that Sawyer did not testify to any bodily harm having been done by Kline during their five-year relationship, other than in an isolated incident in Arizona in March 2013 where he pinned her down by her wrists while he said she was in a tantrum, and gave no testimony that she was afraid Kline would physically harm her.\
'Laying it on thick'
During Thursday's hearing, Kline testified he worried about Sawyer selling his stuff to fuel a drug habit she allegedly had for years, and has spent time in prison for possession with intent to deliver a controlled substance back in 2005, and that he found syringes in his home, some in packs of 100.
Skoff noted that in her report.
"The court understands (Kline) was 'laying it on thick' for the court and does not overlook this in determining capability of the witnesses," the report reads.
Under oath, Kline testified he got the address where Sawyer was staying from a friend who is a state police officer. Kline said the officer ran a license plate number of a truck owned by Michael Snyder, a man who Kline said stayed at his house with Sawyer for a month before moving to Queen Street, Northumberland. Kline spoke with Snyder Sept. 11 and found Sawyer's vehicle.
After that discussion, and a note from Kline Sept. 12, Sawyer called Sunbury police. It was the first time she called police about Kline, but said she did so only to document the contact because the temporary PFA had just been filed, according to Thursday's testimony. She said she wasn't sure if Kline had been served with the PFA.
"It is clear that (Kline) was looking for (Sawyer)," Skoff wrote. "Kline was angry (at Sawyer) for taking items from his home, and using credit cards and writing checks allegedly without his permission."
That anger, according to Skoff, was not enough to grant the final PFA order.
"Even assuming all (Sawyer's) testimony is true and taken in the light most favorable to her, (Kline's) course of conduct does not place (Sawyer) in reasonable fear of bodily injury," the officer wrote. "Even if she were afraid of (Kline) physically harming her, such fear cannot be found to be reasonable given the circumstances of the case."
On the day of the hearing, state police at Milton filed theft-related charges against Sawyer. Kline has filed a civil action against her as well, and Saywer was served with that action during Thursday's hearing.